Continuing the story. Amber knew I was fucking my baby sister. But I couldn’t imagine she would bring my best mate to fuck her with me…
Her ass was a fucking vice, tighter than her pussy ever dreamed of being, that pink ring stretched obscene around my thick cock as I sank balls-deep into my little sister’s virgin hole. Jessie’s tiny body trembled on my lap, her back pressed to my chest, those slim legs splayed wide over my thighs. She whimpered muffled against my palm, tears wetting my skin, but her hips bucked involuntarily with each slow thrust, her unwilling slickness easing the burn. ‘Shh, Jessie—stay still for brother,’ I whispered filthy in her ear, voice rough with lust, nipping her lobe. ‘Your tight little asshole’s gripping my dick so good, milking every inch. Don’t squirm, baby sis—just take it. I’m almost done, gonna fill you up soon.’ She choked out a sob, ‘Sam, please—it hurts so much,’ but I hushed her tighter, arm locked around her waist, bouncing her petite frame harder. The fear of Mom or Dad hearing us in the dead of night only made my cock throb deeper, veins pulsing against her clenching walls.
I couldn’t hold back—grunted low as my balls tightened, slamming up one last time. Hot ropes of cum flooded her ass, spurting thick and deep, painting her insides white while she gasped, body shuddering from the invasion. ‘Fuck, take brother’s load in your ass,’ I rasped, holding her down till I softened just enough. Pulled out slow, watching my seed leak from her gaping rim, a creamy mess dripping down to her pussy lips. She collapsed forward, sobbing quietly, but I just patted her ass like it was nothing, slipping her panties back in place. Ignored the shadow in the doorway—thought it was a trick of the light—tucked my spent cock away and padded back to my room. Amber slept sound in my bed, oblivious, her bubbly tits rising with each breath. Curled up behind her, mind replaying Jessie’s tight heat, already hard again.
That night cracked something in me. Couldn’t stop after that—fucked Jessie whenever the house went quiet, her protests fading to half-hearted whimpers as lust hooked its claws in her. Once addicted to her pussy’s wet grip, I craved her ass more, bending her over the laundry room sink while Mom was in the kitchen, reaming her raw till she bit her lip bloody to stay silent. Made her drop to her knees in the garage, those big innocent eyes watering as I fed her my cock, teaching her to suck deep, tongue swirling my shaft while I gripped her blonde ponytail. Ate her out often, spreading her petite thighs on my bed, lapping her bald slit till she came shaking, her juices sweet on my tongue despite her scared ‘We can’t, Sam.’ The risk turned me feral—fucking her quick in the hallway shadows, heart pounding if footsteps neared. Her body’s betrayal fueled it, that underage pussy clenching around me like it craved the taboo.
My birthday rolled around, and I played it smart—begged Mom and Dad to clear out, give me the house for a barbecue with friends and Amber. ‘Jessie can stay,’ I said casual, eyes on her across the table, already picturing her holes. They bought it, left us to our ‘adult fun.’ Backyard buzzed with smoke and laughter, beers flowing, my best mate Zack slapping my back with his muscular arm, Amber giggling on my lap in her tight shorts. But I itched for Jessie—hadn’t buried my dick in her all day. Caught her eye during games, mouthed ‘Room. Now.’ She paled, mumbled some excuse about homework, slipped inside. I waited five minutes, cock straining, then followed, ignoring Amber’s stare burning into me from the patio. Couldn’t wait—needed her tight underage body wrapped around me again.
Kicked her door shut, found her on the bed in just panties, trembling. ‘Sam, not with everyone here—please,’ she begged, but I shoved her back, yanking her legs apart. ‘Shut up, sis—brother’s birthday wish.’ Ripped her panties off, slammed my thick cock into her soaked pussy, groaning at the familiar squeeze. Pounded her hard, bed slamming the wall, her tiny tits bouncing as she clawed my arms. ‘Your little cunt’s dripping for me, Jessie—admit it, you love brother’s dick stretching you.’ She moaned despite herself, eyes fluttering, but the door creaked open—Zack strolled in, eyes lighting on us, no shock, just a smirk.
‘What the fuck, man?’ I barked, still thrusting deep, unable to stop, balls slapping her ass. ‘Drunk? Lost?’ Zack laughed, shutting the door. ‘Cut the crap, Sam—Amber spilled. You’ve been balls-deep in your baby sis for weeks. I want in.’ My gut twisted—shocked Amber knew, told him? ‘Hell no, Zack—that’s my sister,’ I growled, but couldn’t stop rutting into her, Jessie’s pleading eyes locking on mine, ‘Sam, no—don’t let him!’ Zack stepped closer, bulge massive in his jeans. ‘Wanted to fuck her since she was younger, that petite thing teasing in her shorts. Keep it secret? I join, we share.’ Curiosity hit hard—imagining his huge, muscular body dwarfing her tiny frame, wrecking her holes while I watched. Nodded slow, pulling out slick.
Zack pounced, groping her small tits rough, kissing her neck before tilting her head back, unzipping. ‘Wait, n…’, she protested but he shoved his fat cock down her throat, her lips stretching wide around his girth as he fucked her face, pulling her blonde hair. ‘That’s it, baby girl—so innocent, choking on a big dick like a good little slut.’ She gagged, tears streaming, but he cooed sweet, ‘Such a tiny mouth, taking it all for uncle Zack.’ I froze, cock twitching, till he grunted, ‘Fuck her, Sam—don’t just watch.’ Slowly, transfoixed, I slid back in her pussy, groaning as her walls fluttered around me, syncing thrusts with his throat-fucks. He was brutal—choking her light, yanking hair, but words dripped honey, ‘Look at you, just a baby with two cocks owning you.’ Her pussy twitched around my cock, and I saw, shocked, Jessie put her tiny hand around Zack’s dick, stroking while sucking it.
Did she enjoy all of this?
Then he asked Jessie, easing out of her throat, caressing her cheek, ‘Did your big bro fuck your other hole?’ Jessie just smiled at him shyly and his eyes darkened.
We switched—me on top of her in her dripping cunt, her back to Zack’ chest, him lubing up to claim her ass. Pushed in together, DP’ing her tight body. ‘Oh my god, it’s sooo full, please wait, I don’t know if I want this…’, Jessie whispered, her hands on my chest. We ignored her, dicks sliding through that thin flesh wall, rubbing each other. ‘Fuck, feel that?’ Zack groaned. ‘Her holes gripping us like vices.’
Jessie locked eyes with me and suddenly, a little voice in my head asked me why the hell was I doing? Her blue eyes, my baby sister’s eyes, watched me the same way for years as she was growing up. She was still so young, her tiny tits bouncing as we fucked her, her mouth half open in a moan. But she was still my little sister. And I was sharing her body with my best friend, like a common slut.
‘Ugh, um, ughh… Sam?’, Jessie asked between moans, sensing my reluctance. Then Zack pounded harder, grabbing her neck from behind her, me feeling his cock slamming into her through the thin skin between her holes. Trance hit, I started pounding relentless, Jessie no longer fighting—eyes closed, soft moans escaping as we filled her. Whispered dirty-sweet, ‘Good girl, sis—moan for brother’s cock in your pussy,’ while Zack praised, ‘Tiny ass milking me, baby—made for this.’ Flipped her, switched holes, then hoisted her up standing between us, my cock reaming her ass, Zack’s slamming her pussy. Forgot the party outside, lost in her whimpers turning to gasps, our bodies slick with sweat.
Merciless now, chasing release, grunts filling the room—then Amber at the door, smiling wicked, eyes dark. ‘You like fucking your tiny sister, baby? Her tight underage holes wrapped around your cock? Thinking of her when you fuck me?’ Voice sweet, twisted. Locked eyes with her, the words shattering me—roared as I flooded Jessie’s ass, thick cum pumping deep. Zack bellowed too, unloading in her pussy, our loads mixing as her 15-year-old body convulsed, orgasm ripping through her, moaning loud around our cocks. She slumped, spent, but Amber’s gaze promised more—jealousy? Or joining the taboo?
🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat – Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️